Home > What is islam > A challenge by Ali Sina to all who ever believes that Muhammad was a Prophet

A challenge by Ali Sina to all who ever believes that Muhammad was a Prophet



Please go to his website and defeat him.. His challenge has gone unchallenged for last 10 years..


Sina’s Challenge

I receive many emails from angry Muslims, who sometimes beg me, and sometimes order me to remove this site. I consider both, pleading and bullying, signs of psychopathology. Argumentum ad baculum and argumentum ad misericordiam are both logical fallacies.

If you do not like this site and want me to remove it, instead of acting as a bully or as a victim,  disprove my charges against Muhammad logically.  Not only will I remove the site, I will publicly announce that Islam is a true religion. I will also pay

$50,000 U.S. dollars

to anyone who can disprove any of the dozen of the accusations that I have made against Muhammad. I accuse Muhammad of being:

a narcissist
a misogynist
a rapist

a pedophile
a lecher
a  torturer

a mass murderer
a cult leader
an assassin

a terrorist
a mad man
a looter

I have debated with many Muslims. Their defense of Islam can be summarized in two categories:  

a- Denial of the authenticity of Islamic sources that report the stories of crimes of Muhammad (example: debate with Edip Yukssel, a leader of the Submitters)

b- Moral relativism and situational ethics, e.g., “In those days, pedophilia, assassination, rape, raid, pillage, massacre and lying, were common practices, so Muhammad is innocent because he did what everyone else was doing.” Muslims even go as far as to question the legitimacy of the Golden Rule to claim I do not have any basis to condemn Muhammad. In other words, who can say what is good and what is evil? That is up to the messenger of God to decide. (Example: debate with Yamin Zakaria)

These are the main two arguments that Muslims present in defense of Islam. Any rational person can see they are logical fallacies.    

These charges are irrefutable. You simply can’t disprove them because they are reported in Islamic sources and as such they are as good as confession. You can’t acquit a criminal after he has confessed, unless you plead insanity, which is my point.

Muslims often ask: "Who will judge whether or not an attempt to disprove your accusations against Muhammad and Islam, was successful?"   The readers will be the jury. It is not difficult to see which side is right once both arguments are presented without one side fearing the other. I will publish the debates in this site.  My opponents are also encouraged to publish them in any Islamic site.  Please note that I will not accept face to face debates.  The debates must be in writing. 

Edit 2007/07/29

The above challenge was issued in 2001 and it hasn’t been met yet. See the debates I had with Muslims.  Also see the pathetic attempt of some Muslims trying to refute me here , here, here and here.  Is that all the Muslim world can offer?  Where are the scholars of Islam?  Why such an important task is left to a bunch of amateurs who actually do more damage to Islam?  Isn’t it time that the real scholars come forth and refute my charges?

The truth is that several of the people that debated me were real scholars, such as the eminent Pakistani scholar Mr. Javed Ahmed Ghamidi and his disciple Dr. Khalid Zaheer. This debate is a must read and is available for download.  Dr. Zaheer is a learned man, a moderate Muslim  and a good human being. I have utmost respect for him.

As of this date (2007), I will no longer debate with people who want to debate anonymously. I only debate with reputable scholars. I made this decision because often, Muslims moved by their faith and zealotry, but with little knowledge of Islam, challenge me to debate. They rehash the same tried and refuted arguments that bore everyone and disappear. Then, other Muslims, either accuse me of fabricating those debates or pooh-pooh my opponents for not being scholars. 

As of this day, I am also doubling the reward. If you are not a reputable scholar, you can still win the prize. All you have to do is persuade a scholar to debate with me. If he (she) disproves my charges or can prove that Muhammad was a prophet of God, both you and he (she) will be rewarded $50,000 dollars each. This is to encourage you to write to your admired scholar and convince them that Islam is in danger and that it is their duty to defend it. Once you write to invite someone, please CC a copy to us for announcing the invitation.  Our email is faithfreedom2 (at) gmail.com

Yes, Islam is in grave danger. Never, since its inception, Islam has faced a threat as serious as this. Today, millions of ex-Muslims are questioning the claimed truth of Islam, can make their criticisms heard worldwide, and unlike before, not fear for their lives.  As long as these questions are not answered, this trend is only bound to continue, until the trickle becomes a torrent and the fall of Islam becomes obvious.  In the past, the critics of Islam briefly shined like lamps in darkness, only to be put out by winds of persecution. What is happening today can be likened to the break of the dawn.  Darkness has no chance in front of this much light.  Muslims are waking up and leaving Islam like never before. A spiritual and intellectual revolution is underway.  This is the century of enlightenment of the benighted Muslims. The giant is finally awakening.  The days of Islam are numbered.  This demon of hate and ignorance will be slain by the hands of its own primary victims.  The unity of mankind and the world peace are around the corner.

Please advertise this challenge. Every Muslim must see it.  This is like throwing water on their fire. Nothing will dampen their zeal more than the realization that among a billion Muslims there is not a single scholar who can prove the wild claims of Muhammad, nor acquit him of these grave charges. This unmet challenge has a sobering effect on them.  They can make any excuse, such as, I am not worth their response, that there have been greater men than me who opposed Islam, or that I have been refuted already, but they will not be able to fool themselves.  The more this challenge is circulated, the more Muslims will be forced to remain silent and doubt Islam.  Do not undermine the psychological effect of this impossible challenge.  


Ali Sina


  1. November 27, 2010 at 2:39 pm

    Ali Sina challenge has already been answered on thefreemuslim.com and very soon will be available on thefreemuslim.wordpress.com too!

  2. November 27, 2010 at 4:32 pm

    he has already been refuted on thefreemuslim.com and will be on thefreemuslim.wordpress.com

  3. November 27, 2010 at 4:51 pm

    have you read the bhagvata gita of the hindus? the whole book is about wars fought between the brothers. it teaches you to fight and kill ones own brothers. and you are talking about non violence in hinduism.

    look at the title of your page “defence force” with an image of men holding guns. lol! now, this is what i call hypocrisy. see thefreemuslim.com and read the qur’an with context.

    you are talking against other wives of the prophets without even considering that krishna had 16,108 wives and draupadi had 5 husbands!

    you say muslims spread islam by the sword. muslims ruled over india for 1000 years, then how come 80% of the indian population are still non muslims? why did they not kill or convert your ancestors. your story is full of flaws and nothing more than hate mongering. thefreemuslim.com has already dealt with similar allegations.

    the reason why muslims don’t write about the violence, rapes, sati and bride burning in hinduism is not because they don’t have enough material to write on these topics. the only reason is that they do not believe in spreadin rumours and in hate mongering. it is not difficult for thefreemuslim.com to write about elaborately on these things, but it is simply against their ethics.

    • November 27, 2010 at 5:08 pm

      Yes I have read all the Books and what is in Quran and Islam.
      The Hindu Response is best given by this book. Hope you and your co Religionist can challenge what is in the book and also prove the book wrong.
      Best of Luck and do prove that book point by point
      http://voiceofdharma.org/books/tcqp/ (The Calcutta Quran Petition )

      Please don’t be nice to Hindus. Put everything which is bad in Hinduism so that we can correct it and also tell us how much the Muslims are nice to Hindus from your own books. We would really like to know why Muslims killed 80 Million Hindus. If this is Islamic Love then what will be Islamic Hate..(Wipe every Hindu out of World)
      So no Mercy on Hindus…We know your Mercy already by the 80 Million Hindus killed and would like to see your hate.

  4. November 27, 2010 at 6:10 pm

    The book you have mentioned is full of hadith stories. A lot of educated Muslims are already aware that most of these books are nothing but lies that have been fabricated against the prophet. As far as the verses from the Qur’an is concerned, please take time to visit my website thefreemuslim.com

  5. November 27, 2010 at 6:26 pm

    The first question to ask is “Does the Qur’an sanction the killing of any innocent Hindus?” If not, then were the Muslim rulers practicing Islam by any standards, provided they did kill the innocent Hindus? If they killed the Hindus who were innocent then they will be accountable before God on the day of judgment. I can not bring them back and execute them, but believe me I would if I had a choice. It is life for life in Islam.

    Those who kill innocent Hindus are the worst examples of Muslims and they are nothing but transgressors. Believe me, they won’t go unpunished if you believe in the concept of Swarga and Narak. Any unprovoked violence of any kind against any human being is totally unacceptable in Islam. The Qur’an preaches to protect even your enemies if they seek protection and escort them to a place of safety if they are at risk of any harm. I have already explained this on my website thefreemuslim.com under the heading Ali Sina Challenge – Looter.

  6. November 27, 2010 at 6:38 pm

    You keep talking about several books that have been written on Islam. Most of these books are simply full of garbage. The only book that I follow is the Qur’an and I have already defended this on my website. I can not guarantee the authenticity of the other books as they are neither from God, nor from Muhammad (P). They are just lies “attributed” to the prophet to justify the cruelty of those who wanted to violate the rules of Islam for their own agenda.

  7. vik
    January 17, 2011 at 3:31 pm

    no matter what you say thefreemuslim, god’s theories has no more life span…

  8. February 14, 2011 at 2:47 pm

    al sina i challenge you and all party god is one
    and prophet muhammad hazur pak our all world owner and he is rehmat ul
    ala mean.all world sit with me and my brother we will prove it,
    and also u u lose ur challenge i m not doing this for money.
    u talking about bible ur father in church they change bible ayat,
    only for money how much is ur life.god say also in bible and quran,
    i m alone and dont make firka.in quran say allah says muhammad i didnt send u in world then i cant make world what is ur,for example ur name is
    al sina but b4 ur burn and when u come world only child one day
    if no body take ur name so what u call ur self.al sina 00923216112373,
    my number i m from pakistan this all world owner is pbuh only and helso
    no body in world just only god.also in bible u can read god say onlwhy
    me in world and one god make all too do everybody identy me god is a name
    but he have wajood,who make u,one person death then go near his body and
    ask and put his hand,he is finish our body is finish but who god our
    inside he alive no body death and no body there,where u from just i come
    in ur country and i prove it god is everywhere and he dont have any son,
    did u realize it who r u and where u came from,no body can get where is
    the last river land but i know and i can prove it with profe and
    all world live telecast do with me u call all ur father but i m alone
    and surely i will b win and u put ur hand on my fit,do u accept it now

  9. munib
    March 11, 2011 at 5:18 pm

    naughty brat Ali sina.prophet Mohammad(saw) used to give invitation to disbelievers, were he said now to kill those who disbelief.barking dog Sina

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: